From: markodegard@...
Message: 64
Date: 1999-10-12
I have some quotes and personal notes on this book here:
http://homepages.msn.com/LibraryLawn/mark_odegard/Indo-European.html
I should state this is not a formal document, but represents personal notes, and some personal speculations, nothing more. Ryan and Pitman have impeccable credentials as earth scientists; their speculations on archaeology, linguistics and ethnography are unhelpful. The original paper that announced the discovery of this event was published in the journal Science; those of you with access to this journal may wish to consult it.
The implications of the Black Sea flood are for the coalescence
of proto-Indo-European, and not for its eventual breakup. My own views
-- which are just an inclination and could change at any moment -- are
that the earliest stages of PIE are probably found where Marija
Gimbutas suggests -- in the Volga-Ural complex, with the Samara River
as the linchpin, with early extension westward into what became Sredny
Stog.