Re: Is Yoga a Hindu tradition

From: shivkhokra
Message: 67207
Date: 2011-03-02

No. There is a full movmement underway which seeks to make yoga an "export" from the "west" and an "import" into India. Specifically the claim is Britishers taught Indians gymnastics which Indians rebottled/repackaged as Yogic postures, with funny sounding names, and called them yoga-asana! In the meanwhile west forgot about these gymnastic postures and gave credit to Hindus/Indians for the yoga but now some "smart" scholars are figuring out the truth and setting the record straight.

You can follow the funny threads from the experts at Indo-Eurasian_Research here:
a) Yoga is not Hindu
b) Yoga's Soul
c) Origin of Chakras

Shivraj
--- In cybalist@yahoogroups.com, "G&P" <G.and.P@...> wrote:
>
> >Recently, the post-modernist cum Leftist writer Meera Nanda wrote an
> article denying that Hathayoga can be called Hindu or Vedic. ...
>
> I would happily guess that she means, "What is called Hathayoga in the West
> today has nothing to do with the traditional Hathayoga of Hinduism." I
> don't think the Hindu roots of yoga need defending.
>
> Peter
>