Re: That old Odin scenario ...

From: tgpedersen
Message: 58326
Date: 2008-05-03

> > > I agree with Kortlandt and Shchukin: it is impossible to
> > > identify a "Slavic" group as of your mentioned dates <72-58 BCE>.

I would disagree. If we theoretically allow multi-ethnic and
multi-lingual areas, we could identify (Proto-Proto-!) Slavs with the
farmers in Zarubyntsi and Przeworsk, later surviving in a band between
Niemcza and Dniepr (this is the "Polish archaologists'" part), later
reinforced with (Proto-) Slavs from Dniepr (the mainstream part).

As for the Kortlandt quote, he is obviously accepting the mainstream
view, which influences some of his temporal estimates.