Re: New file uploaded to cybalist

From: fournet.arnaud
Message: 57720
Date: 2008-04-20

----- Original Message -----
From: "Peter P" <roskis@...>
>
>http://groups.yahoo.com/group/cybalist/files/prefinnic%20vocabulary%20reconstructed.htm

>> jouppe <jouppe@...>
>
=========
>It's an interesting and useful list. I have a question about the
>numbers kahdeksan 8, and yhdeksän, 9. SSA seems to have a slightly
>different explanation. See message...

>http://tech.groups.yahoo.com/group/cybalist/message/38422

>Can you comment further?

> Peter P
=========

I will provide one more explanation.

One is PU *wuGka
Two is PU *kukto- or *kiktu

Privative suffix : -ikt-
Locative *so

Eight : with two missing :
*kukto-ikt-so > *kahtäktso

Nine : with one missing
*wuGka-ikt-so > *wüGkäktso

Finnish displays intrusion : eight on nine
hence kahdeksan
and rearranged üh-dek-san

Cheremis also displays this intrusion.
*kahtäkso > *kaNdesh
*wüGkäktso > üNgesh > rearranged üNdesh
NB : there is no intrusion of -n- but assimilation.

Mordvin has deletion of the second syllable :
hence kah--ktso > kafkso / kafksa
hence wüG--ktso > wei(h)kso / wei(h)ksa

There is no IE *dek in any of these words.

Arnaud