Re: HERG / HEARG : BEOWULF'S SACRED GROVE & C. ARABIC "HRG"

> I was talking about cases of actual -h- in Germanic
> or other IE languages.
>
> And PIE *H has more phonetic values than you think
> as already stated :
> *z *dz *s? *ts? *dh? are *H2
> *&(ayin) is not at all occasional.
>

[Goading deleted - Richard.]

>
> Arnaud
>
> ==============

I did not say that *¿ was "occasional".

I wrote that PAA *¿ _occasionally_ shows up in PIE as *H; normally, it shows
up as *y.

Patrick

================

I don't think &ayin can surface in PIE as *y
in any IE language.
It's a form of good old H2.

But if you think & > PIE y
what are your examples ?
(Please no unreadable pages)

Arnaud

===============