Re: The meaning of life: PIE. *gWiH3w-

From: fournet.arnaud
Message: 53028
Date: 2008-02-14

Yeah, I'm just that good. You see, I looked at a Tillamook grammar
that I have and saw nothing in common with PIE. The verbal morphology
is completely different. The nominal morphology is completely
different. Personal pronouns are some of the most stable lexical
elements in a language.
Ray
==========
Wrong
French Italian
j' aime am-o
tu aimes am-i
il aime am-a
on aime am-amo
vous aimez am-ate
ils aiment am-ano

Italian and French verbal morphologies
are completely different
Prefixal in FRench / suffixal in ITalian
What does it prove ?

I don't believe in
that *fetishist* morphology dogma.

Arnaud
====================

If you want to prove your case
start by presenting us with the Yakhontov 35 word-lists for PIE and
Proto-Salish and let us know the sound correspondences.
Ray

============
What is this 35 word list ?

It might be fun.

Arnaud

===========