Re[6]: [tied] Economic analysis of Indian History: meaning of Aryan

From: Brian M. Scott
Message: 52743
Date: 2008-02-12

At 12:13:05 AM on Tuesday, February 12, 2008, kishore
patnaik wrote:

> Let us not discuss semantics.

That's a very strange statement, in view of the fact that
you apparently want to discuss the semantic range of 'the
word Arya' -- specifically, whether that range includes any
economic senses. I assume that it really refers to my
comments on your misuse of the word 'cognate'. They are
hardly a matter of mere semantics, and I'm not inclined to
be particularly helpful to someone who can't be bothered to
learn to use even the most basic terminology correctly.

> You just now given one more sociological meaning ' high
> born'

According to the references header, your post is a response
to one of mine, and I certainly have not given any such
thing.

> I repeat that I am looking for economic interpretations of
> the word Arya .

[...]

Brian