Re: Nubia (WAS- Re: Limitations of the comparative method)

From: fournet.arnaud
Message: 52143
Date: 2008-02-01

> ==================
I just checked in Wörterbuch to refresh my memory, and found that the
spelling is nb except for "Rohstoff", then it is nb.w (gold nuggets or
dust). -w is, after all, the Egyptian plural suffix.

The Coptic spelling is noub so I cannot understand where anyone
knowledgeable would get *nuw.

Perhaps a copying error?

Patrick

***
I repeat :
According to Loprieno's reconstructions,
> > Coptic : <noub> or <nouf> to be read [nuw]
> > Egyptian skeleton : n_b_w
> > Reconstruction : na:baw
> > Later on : [nu:b > nuw]

I add
Loprieno, 1995 Ancient Egyptian, Cambridge.
p. 248 note n° 58

Cf. Crum
http://www.metalog.org/files/crum/221.gif

noub and nouf.

Arnaud
=============