Re: [Courrier indésirable] Re: [tied] Re: Limitations of the compar

From: fournet.arnaud
Message: 52098
Date: 2008-01-30

You may believe if you choose that xrusos comes from Hebrew Harûz but I
prefer to believe that it is a unique derivation from PIE *ghre:u-(**s- ).
Why would the Greeks need to borrow a word for 'gold'?

Do you have access to the argumentation supporting it as a loan?
 
============
According to a friend of mine, who is an archeologist,
no metal can be very ancient,
including gold.
So it's not impossible that most of these words are loanwords
including my *H_H_w-s.
especially in view of Arabic dhahb < *dahb.
H2 out of *d is not possible.
It requires an already evolved form
*dahb
then
*dhahb
then
*zahb
loanword
HaHw-
 
Arnaud