Re: IS PIE * DERU EXCLUSIVELY INDO-EUROPEAN ?

From: Patrick Ryan
Message: 51909
Date: 2008-01-27

The root for 'tree' is not *deru-, a common root-form of **der- + *-w.
 
Few of us belong to the school of "If it does not work otherwise, just segment it differently!".
 
There is no *d- prefix in PIE.
 
Patrick
 
----- Original Message -----
Sent: Thursday, January 24, 2008 2:15 PM
Subject: Re: [tied] IS PIE * DERU EXCLUSIVELY INDO-EUROPEAN ?

[I've trimmed this, and will probably do so with another seven posts that will appear shortly, because excessive quoting has caused Yahoo to identify them as probable spam. Please try to be selective in what you quote from previous posts!

I've deleted the HTML version of the post - note Technical Recommendation 1:
"Post plain-text messages rather than HTML. Fancy backgrounds, colours and fonts are dispensable. "

- Richard.]

'The Egyptian Chronicles' wrote:
> However, according to Classical Arabic sources, "drw" (d : an emphatic dad) is a species of trees of sweet odor growing mostly in Yemen. Some say it is the btm (1), from which the bitumen is extracted; others refer it to the terebinth-tree. Drw also stands for the great oak growing in the Yemeni mountains, and the cancamum tree growing in Arabia (Yemen).

> Further, from the tree "drw" tar is extracted.

Yes, it is exclusively indo-european because the root is ?or-
not *d-oru, Cf
latin ar-bor
tokharian ore

Connection with Arabic d_r_w is absurd from the start.
The root is ?_r-

Have you subscribed to a "beat-Ruhlen" competition ?

Arnaud