Mr Pedersen,
To be frank,
I am quite fed up with your
general approach.
You are always indulging in un-proved mysterious
substrate inventions,
most of which are highly self-contradictory in the
first place,
like claiming that Central-Europe is "vasconic"
then "probably Celtic" then "why not whatnot,
including PIE",
You are always dodging questions,
and answering a clear question with a
mountain
of un-sorted ruhlenesque "data" that neither prove
nor mean nothing,
Hundreds of words mitch-matched together in the
worst bedlam,
drowning a clear issue into an ocean of
nothingness,
You are always claiming answers are not
answers,
although I have been very clear
You are always distorting answers beyond any
limit,
You have been making absurd claims
like "Boulogne's area was
Dutch-speaking"
something that contradicts every single bit of
information
we have on this area.
I consider this assertion has been made
shreds.
You have proved **wrong** in the clearest
way,
but you still pop up with absurd questions and
mails,
that are meaningless and off the
point.
In fact, some other people on the forum are nearly
honest and sympathetic,
like My best pet M. P.R,
when compared with
your general approach
which is an obnoxious compound of inventions,
forgeries,
denials of data, dreamish absurdities,
substrate obsessions,
and I probably lack words to make an exhaustive
description
of your mails.
Arnaud
----- Original Message -----
Sent: Monday, January 21, 2008 11:09
AM
Subject: [Courrier indésirable] Re:
[tied] Sard
>
> > > > Compare
> > > > PIE *seH1-
"seed, sow"
> > > > Tchadic HAusa : shu:kâ "seed" <
*soH1-ka
> > > Proto-root *s_H1 "to sow, to disperse".
>
> Data :
> > PIE : *s_h1-
> > Hausa : sh_H-k
> >
Vocalic scheme in Hausa : like : tomâ
> > as in ruwa "water" <
*r_w "to flow".
>
> ========
>
> I can't see that it
follows that they are not later
> loans, as you claim.
>
Torsten
> ======
> I see what you mean :
> This root is a
Vasconico-atlasian substrate word.
> It was borrowed by PIE and a
Touareg Non Governmental Org brought
> it to Hausa on Camel backs
kindly provided by M. Kuhn Foundation.
Are you saying that the Hausa
had no agriculture?
Torsten