Re: How many velar series in P.I.E? (was Re: [tied] *kW- "?")

From: glen gordon
Message: 40152
Date: 2005-09-20

>>> There is evidence for *k^a-, although it is
>>> admittedly rare.

Miguel inputs:
> *k^ad- "fall", *k^as- "hare, grey", *k^ank-
> "branch", k^at- "fight".

And note that this is unproblematic for the uvular
interpretation of IE because *a is supposed to be
capable of being a valid phoneme anyway. It would
violate one of the most basic language universals
if the IE theory were to lack a [-high] phoneme
afterall. So, I would just write these as *kad-,
*kas-, *kanq- and *kat- respectively with plain *k
and phonemic (non-coloured) *a.


= gLeN




__________________________________
Yahoo! Mail - PC Magazine Editors' Choice 2005
http://mail.yahoo.com