Re: [tied] PIE *CVC conjugation

From: Patrick Ryan
Message: 38380
Date: 2005-06-06

Jens,
 
I would be very interested in your comments (or any other interested person) on the following proposed scheme for earliest PIE conjugational bases:
 
 
PUNCTUAL
 
*CéC²-
 
 
DURATIVE
 
*CéC²-e-
 
 
INTENSIVE
 
*Cé-CoC²-
 
*Ce-CóC²-
 
 
I presume that the augment (*é-) was not obligatory as this stage to indicate non-present time.
 
I also presume that -*i  was later added to distinguish present from imperfect
 
Combined with athematic secondary and thematic primary endings:
 
 
*CéC²- + -*m = transitive aorist (now called injunctive)
 
*CéC²- + -*oH = intransitive aorist (stative)
 
*CéC²e- + -*m = transitive durative (now called imperfect; with -*i, later present)
 
*CéC²e- + -*oH = intransitive durative (now called subjunctive)
 
*Cé-CoC²- + -*m = durative intensive (now called reduplicated present)
 
*Ce-CóC²-  + -*oH = punctual intensive (now called perfect)
 
 
Do you think this organizational pattern has any merit at all?
 
 
Patrick