Re: [tied] Re: Rise of the Feminine (was: -osyo 3)

From: Harald Hammarstrom
Message: 32310
Date: 2004-04-25

> Starostin has recently published what seems a careful analysis of
> 100-word lists (Mother Tongue Issue VIII, 2003), which shows that
> with the exception of Sandawe and Hadze, whose inclusion remains
> uncertain, Khoisan is a genetic unit.

I haven't seen his analysis but similar approaches have fared ill before.
I actually had the chance to speak to Tom Gu"ldemann a few weeks ago and
he grouped Khoisan into 6 genetic unit: Hadza, Sandawe, South Khoisan,
Central Khoisan + Kwadi, Northern Khoisan and #Ho~a. The novelty is that
Kwadi was tentatively joined with Central Khoisan since Gu"ldemann
got access to the unpublished field notes.
mvh
Harald