Re: [tied] Re: Derivation Rules from Old Slavic to Romanian

m_iacomi wrote:

>
> Of course you _may_ suppose what you want, including green elephants
> flying over your desktop. You _should_ not, though, if you want to
> use efficiently your time on planet Earth and not wasting others'
> time with nonsensical ascii lines.

I see as usual the discution between us takes a path which is not
recomandable to continue. Let me dream my elephants, ok? I don't know
why you are in fact afraid. There are shcolars which demonstrated that
Rom. is the Latin lang. so, why stil bother about other opinions,
special opinions of dreamers? Let them dream:-)

>> The books you are talking about have their limits due the idea
>> they want to exprime.
>
> You are not in position to know what those limits are.

You are not in position to decide about my position:-)

>
>>> BS. Romanian inherited word is "zi", with article "ziua", giving
>>> a reconstructed analogical form "ziuã", there is nothing to wonder
>>> about (-ua < -illa, see also Miguel's post).
>>
>> Ah! so, you are so sure as the poorman in the church. Keep on it.
>
> It's obvious for anyone but those wearing blinkers. On the article
> -ua we had already a discussion which you certainly forgot, as usual.

No. I promised to Piotr I won't reopen the subject until I don't show
clear that the "-uã" is not from "-illa". That is an ABSURDUM
phoneticaly but I stop.. I said I don't reopen it now.

>> Your meaning in Late Latin is not kept in your language. See "now".
>
> You are making even less sense as usual (if possible). I did not
> advocate for "hodie" > "azi", that's by all means your invention,
> and I am not interested by the semantic problem you create. I just
> pointed out that the tendency [d] > [dz] > [z] in some phonetic
> conditions belongs to a late stage of VL, it is not a feature to
> be supposedly found _only_ in (Northern) Thracian, as your fixation
> still goes on.
>
> Marius Iacomi

I said that "azi" should be seen in relationship with "hodie" , I did
not said that "hodie" > "azi".
The "d" > "z" was plenty discussed here too and we learned that it
happened just in a part of the world ..

Just a personal question if you allow me, please. Do your children speak
Romanian?

Alex