Re: [tied] Methodology: Throw it out the window, folks

From: Glen Gordon
Message: 10460
Date: 2001-10-20

>IEW 343 *e(:)sr(gW), EIEC 71 under *h1esh2r "Cf. the derivative in
>Lat sanguen (< *h1sh2en-gW-en-)".

Until you can supply me with an abundant list of words ending
in vocalic /-r/ in Sanskrit, your reconstructions are irrelevant.

Latin /sanguen/ and /asrk/ do not correlate due to
differences not only in form but also the lack of /-r-/ in Latin.
Without /-r/, the word cannot be interpreted within the bounds
of IE grammar. In ignorance, why, who cares about making sense?
We could just as well derive /sanguen/ from *senghW-, *se-n-gh-,
or *s-neighW-!

Now, what logical objections forbid the connection with /sanus/
"healthy"?

- love gLeN


_________________________________________________________________
Get your FREE download of MSN Explorer at http://explorer.msn.com/intl.asp