Re: Mlecchita Vikalpa

From: markodegard@...
Message: 8680
Date: 2001-08-22

S.Kalyanaraman writes:
>
> Some keys to decode the script of the civilization are based on a
> monograph presented at the Second International Conference of Asian
> Scholars, Berlin on Aug. 9, 2001. It is at:
> http://sarasvati.simplenet.com/Sarasvati01.pdf
>
> I would deeply appreciate critical comments.

It has 117 pages in *.pdf format!

*ANY* claims to decipherment of the Indus Civilization script have to
be regarded with great scepticism. Along with Linear A and the
Phaistos disk, many claims for 'decipherment' have been made, and all
have been shown to be utterly false. The Ventris wannabes turn out to
be mainly self-deluded.

The usual bet is that if it's ever deciphered, it will be show to be
encoding a Dravidian language. It could just as well, however, encode
something related to Burushaski (a language isolate).